Panda Persuasion

My roommate the Panda and I fight a lot. He’s very good at finding some gaps in my logic, jamming his paw in it and jerking my whole argument apart by outing me as a silly, over-privileged, white girl who has no idea what the things she so passionately talks about actually mean. Poverty. Racism. Rugby. He’s good.

But this Tuesday, we got into a debate over vegetarianism, and this time, I didn’t end up in a corner licking my wounds from the battlefield. To be fair, 12 years of vegetarianism (throw in about 5 steaks, 4 bites of a DΓΆner and a couple of very guilty burger moments) prepared me well for this one. I had my first blood-sweat-and-tears fight over vegetarianism when I was twelve with my 21 year old brother and realized that I could only escape this debate, if I avoided eating around other people all together.

To be honest, the debate get’s a bit old after a few years.

table vegetarianism

However, in this particular case, the debate became a little more heated than I usually let it get. After calling the Panda an idiot, yelling a few things that were completely off-topic and punching the couch helplessly, we were interrupted and I had a little time to cool off.

I decided, it would be best to let a third party speak. Obviously, one that would make my case.

So we watched Earthlings, a terribly brutal documentary about mass meat production & co. produced by Joaquim Phoenix that you can watch for free, if you’re up for it. To roughly quote Joaquim: “As a consumer of animal products you actually have no right to not watch it.” I have to say, though, that it consists of some of the most horrible scenes I’ve ever seen. And this comes from a German kid who had to watch all those concentration camp videos at high school… I cried throughout most of it and certainly didn’t keep my eyes open all of the time.

Yet, the documentary shows probably not even the most extreme forms of animal abuse. The message is clear: this is happening, right now and all over the world, and you should give a shit about it, if you have animal products in your fridge, wardrobe or bathroom.

Panda made a joke about falling asleep when it was over. I didn’t even have the energy to go at his throat at this point. But then he asked me some questions and I could see a new uneasiness in his face, the wrinkled forehead of reconsideration.

I think the documentary pushes it too far for the mainstream meat-eater, so I diluted the documentary’s message a little bit by saying that a lot of people argue a strong case for supporting organic and ethical meat production as a more realistic alternative to mass meat production than total abstinence.

Well, what can I say. The next day around noon I received a text message saying that Panda would go vegetarian for a month to see how he felt about it. I’m going to cook the shit out of quinoa, tofu and beans this month!

panda

Advertisements

16 thoughts on “Panda Persuasion

  1. why do you argue vegetarism with the only bear, born as a predator but only eating bambus? shouldn’t he be on your vegieteam?

    • Well, this one needed persuasion. But true, I do think it was an easier one, since it’s in their nature (AS IT IS IN HUMAN NATURE YES I’M USING EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE THAT POINT) πŸ™‚

  2. Pingback: apples and anarchy

  3. This is great and hilarious! Thanks for the link to Earthlings, I will definitely check it out.

    I’m not sure where I sit. I’m like 80% vegetarian. Meat has almost always been off our grocery shopping. I tend to still order it when I’m eating out.

    I think I am subconsciously inching closer and closer to vegetarianism but I don’t know if I’ll ever get there. I’m not opposed to animal that are ethically raised and slaughtered. But then again there is the whole environmental reasons for abstaining from meat. Economic reasons – high cost, etc – are also a factor but not that big.

    I’m not sure. That whole tri-fecta of reasons are very logically convincing for me. But I’m not there yet. Maybe soon???

    • Thank you!!
      I just read the intro of this –> http://www.rivercottage.net/users/River%20Cottage%20Veg%20Every%20Day!/
      amazing meat-eater’s veggie cookbook yesterday and almost shed a tear. I was so happy about what he said about not eating meat as a meat-eater: no pressure, no wrinkled forehead, just appreciation for yummy, healthy, good food and healthy, happy animals somewhere out there that don’t have to be killed for a complete dinner. (Also, the recipes are. just. so. GREAT. but I don’t want to advertise too much…) My point being: it’s not about denying yourself meat altogether for me. It’s about caring about the whole picture. Watching that movie is definitely a way to show that you do! So thanks again, this time on behalf of all those other earthlings πŸ™‚
      And: the Panda is still going and LOVING it!!! Who would have thought?! He finds it so much fun to find out about all these new ways to feed himself. The good conscience seems to be more like the cherry on top πŸ™‚ I’ll write about his experience soon, I think. It’s so interesting…

      • Oh I discovered early in undergraduate life from the hare krishna guy on campus that vegetarian meals can be the most delicious things you could ever make!

        Now only if I learn those recipes, I’m pretty sure I would have no need for meat ever! πŸ™‚

        On a more serious note, I think it’s a bit of difficult process for me to completely pull away. After all the societal propaganda growing up about meat as food, it’s a bit difficult to pull away. Logically, all the reasons make sense to me. I’m sure I’ll get there one day soon πŸ™‚

  4. Pingback: Persuaded the Panda | s y s t e m c o n s c i e n c e m e

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s